Waiting for Wave, Playing with Sidewiki

In : Uncategorized, Posted by Laura Blankenship on Oct.10, 2009

Google has launched Wave, a new social media tool that’s supposed to be a game changer in private beta.  While I’m waiting for my invite (pick me, please!), I decided to have a look at their slightly older release, Sidewiki. I must say, it’s pretty cool.  By adding a simple toolbar, which takes one click, you can add comments to any web site, which show up alongside the site.  Further, you can post those same comments to Twitter, to your blog, to Facebook, and more.  If a site has comments, you can see them by clicking the little text balloon and voila! find out what others are thinking. Some people have suggested that this usurps commenting on blogs or fractures that conversation, and that may be true, but for sites without comments, it offers a really easy way to make comments.  I can imagine lots of educational uses, too.  For example, students might be required to comment on a site for class and sidewiki provides easy tools for that comment to be shared, even via email.  There are tools that already do this, like Diigo, but with many schools already usuing Google’s apps, this offers better integration with that toolset.

Michael Clarke has argued at The Scholarly Kitchen, that sidewiki means institutions will no longer have control over their message.  I think that’s long been true, with blogs and Twitter and other media.  But it is true that there’s potential for someone to see what others think right from your site rather than through a Google search that lands them on a disgruntled employee’s blog. Now the disgruntled employee’s comments might appear side-by-side with your slick marketing campaign.  Prof Hacker has a good write up and some interesting comments about how good or bad the tool is.

The whole concept is nothing super new, but whenever Google starts doing something, it often becomes mainstream.  Whether it’s sidewiki or Diigo or something else, I think the idea of being able to comment on websites and share those comments widely is here to stay.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
2 comments for this entry:
    2 Responses to "Waiting for Wave, Playing with Sidewiki"
  1. #1 Bryan Alexander

    I agree with you about Google’s influence, but admit to two skepticisms.

    First, the restriction to that toolbar seriously limits Sidewiki’s user base.

    Second, such annotation projects tend not to work. I taught with one, once, that did well, until M_cr_s_ft killed it.

  2. #2 Laura

    Yeah, I agree the toolbar kinda sucks and so far, I haven’t seen a huge number of sites with annotations. But, I think the “idea” that people can comment might spur some changes. Course, people have been commenting via blogs for years! It just wasn’t localized.

Leave a Reply